The rules do not include a clause that allows negitave comments on bad designs. The marketplace rules which you yourself agreed to when joining clearly state
Negative Comments, Negative Criticism or Trashing Threads
Negative comments, trashing or criticism are not allowed in members threads. Talkfreelance is a friendly community and we expect this policy to extend to our Marketplace. We wish you the best of luck with your advertisement and realise that negative comments can impact severely on your sale. In light of this, please note that negative comments will be removed; offenders may be warned and possibly placed on a vacation. Keep it friendly please.
|
@damien
Yes, it is necessary because it could hurt their sale badly. The gallery showcase is the place for critique where you could make comments on this design. The punishments need to be harsh because in reality the worst thing you can do is ruin somebodies sale, we just cant have that in a forum that claims to be friendly.