Both entries appear more 'techy' rather than 'pro'. To me pro would be simplicity and creativity mixed, and providing good content. A game site, if thats what it is, cannot be classed as 'pro' in the same context.

Nice starts, and im sure, with work would be very nice, the second is the better imo. Personally the first one, seems cartoonish, its the font used and the blue colour that does it. the header on the second template is definently a vast improvement on the original.

Good luck Regards Stillt